Management & Organization

What Sets Successful CEOs Apart: Deciding, Engaging, Adapting, and Delivering

Share this article
LINEFacebook

Reposted compilation (HBR; Botelho, Powell, Kincaid, Wang)

Storage information

Bookmarks and reading positions are stored in this browser. Manage and back them up in My Reading.

Collected in Robin Shen’s Field Notes · Content type and attribution are shown above

English version published 2026-11-08 with AI assistance. Attribution, source notes, and verification limits are retained in the text. 中文原文

Reading guide

This article ties CEO performance to behaviors you can practice, not charisma or pedigree: deciding quickly and with conviction, engaging stakeholders, adapting proactively, and delivering reliably. It's a useful lens for leaders to check how they work.

Key points

  • Deciding, engaging, adapting, and delivering reliably are behaviors you can practice
  • A correlation in a research sample is not a personal guarantee of success
Management & Organization thematic illustration
Management & Organization · Thematic illustration · AI generated

Full text — English translation

Fact-check notes (2026-10-31): 1. Source: "What Sets Successful CEOs Apart" by Elena Lytkina Botelho, Kim Rosenkoetter Powell, Stephen Kincaid, and Dina Wang (HBR, 2017). The full English original was obtained from a copy on the HEC website; the Chinese translator and repost path are not credited. Source: https://cae1.hec.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/What-sets-successful-CEOs-Apart.pdf 2. The figures of 12x, 6.7x, 15x, 75%, and the main percentages match the English original. They come from the CEO Genome Project's analysis of a sample of executive assessments and the authors' interpretation. They don't mean a typical CEO who adopts a behavior will become that many times more likely to succeed, and they don't establish causation. Source: https://cae1.hec.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/What-sets-successful-CEOs-Apart.pdf 3. The interview quotes and cases match the original article (quotes below are given in their original English). This site didn't separately interview anyone or access the underlying research data. "Work ethic" refers to how hard people work, not moral character. Source: https://cae1.hec.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/What-sets-successful-CEOs-Apart.pdf ---- What makes a successful CEO? #HarvardBusinessReview Research finds that successful CEOs tend to show four specific behaviors that have proven critical to performance. Boards that focus on these four behaviors when selecting and developing leaders can greatly improve their odds of hiring the right CEO. The research also shows that a significant share of executives who deliberately strengthen these behaviors greatly improve their chances of becoming high-performing CEOs. #DecidingWithSpeedAndConviction There are plenty of stories about CEOs who confidently turned things around and led their companies to big wins. But we found that high-performing CEOs don't necessarily stand out for making brilliant decisions all the time. What sets them apart is that they're more decisive. They make decisions earlier, faster, and with conviction, and they do it consistently. It's their habitual style. Our data show that people described as "decisive" were 12 times more likely to be high-performing CEOs. Interestingly, the highest-IQ executives in our programs, the ones who enjoy complex thinking, were sometimes the most prone to hesitation. Their decisions were often high quality, but because they chased the perfect answer, they took too long and couldn't clearly set priorities. Their teams paid a steep price. These smart but slow leaders became bottlenecks. Their teams either got frustrated, which drove away valuable talent, or stalled, which ground the whole organization to a halt. So it's no surprise that when we looked closely at executives who scored low on decisiveness, only 6% scored low because they decided too fast. Most of them (94%) scored low because they didn't decide enough, or decided too slowly. High-performing CEOs understand that a wrong decision is usually better than no decision. As former Greyhound CEO Stephen Gorman, who led the bus company through a turnaround, put it: "A bad decision was better than a lack of direction. Most decisions can be undone, but you have to learn to move with the right amount of speed." Decisive CEOs recognize that they can't wait for perfect information. "Once I have 65% certainty around the answer, I have to make a call," says Jerry Bowe, CEO of the private-label manufacturer Vi-Jon. That doesn't stop decisive CEOs from actively gathering different viewpoints and polling a small, handpicked "kitchen cabinet" of advisers. They make sure those advisers are trustworthy: people who will give honest opinions and sound judgment. Engaging for impact Once a CEO has set the company's direction, they have to win buy-in from employees and other stakeholders. We found that strong CEOs strike a good balance between attending to stakeholders' priorities and relentlessly driving performance. They start by being highly attuned to what stakeholders need and what motivates them, then push people to deliver, rallying everyone around creating value. In our data, CEOs who were good at engaging stakeholders with a focus on results were 75% more successful in the role. CEOs who are good at bringing people together plan and execute disciplined communication and influence strategies. "With any big decision, I create a stakeholder map of the key people who need to be on board," explains Madeline Bell, CEO of Children's Hospital of Philadelphia. "I identify the detractors and their concerns, and then I think about how I can take the energy that they might put into resistance and channel it into something positive. I make it clear to people that they're important to the process and they'll be part of a win. But at the end of the day, you have to be clear that you're making the call and you expect them on board." CEOs who engage stakeholders well don't waste energy trying to please everyone, and they don't leave their teams to face painful decisions alone. Those are the mistakes underperforming CEOs make. Seasoned CEOs convince their teams that they can lead them to success, and that wins support, even when the CEO's moves are uncomfortable or unpopular. In pursuing the company's goals, strong CEOs don't shy away from conflict. In fact, in our analysis, two-thirds of the CEOs who excelled at engagement also scored high on managing conflict. That ability to handle disagreement also helps candidates land the top job. When we looked at leaders who rose to CEO faster than average, one of their most distinctive traits was a willingness to resolve disputes. #AdaptingProactively How important is the ability of companies and leaders to adapt to a fast-changing environment? Our analysis shows that highly adaptable CEOs were 6.7 times more likely to succeed. CEOs told us again and again that adaptability is critical. When asked what sets effective CEOs apart, Dominic Barton, global managing partner of McKinsey & Company, immediately said: "It's dealing with situations that are not in the playbook. As a CEO you are constantly faced with situations where a playbook simply cannot exist. You'd better be ready to adapt." Most CEOs know they have to split their attention across short-, medium-, and long-term horizons, but adaptable CEOs spent far more of their time, as much as 50%, thinking about the long term. Other executives spent an average of 30%. We believe a long-term focus helps because it makes CEOs more likely to catch early signals. Highly adaptable CEOs regularly tap into broad flows of information. They scan wide networks and diverse data sources and find connections in information that at first seems unrelated to their business. As a result, they spot change earlier and make strategic moves to take advantage of it. Adaptable CEOs also understand that setbacks are an inevitable part of change, so they treat mistakes as chances to learn and grow. In our sample, CEOs who saw setbacks as failures were half as likely as average to succeed. Successful CEOs, by contrast, openly and matter-of-factly admit where they stumbled and why, and give concrete examples of how they adjusted to do better next time. Likewise, aspiring CEOs with a similar attitude, which Stanford's Carol Dweck calls a "growth mindset," were more likely to reach the top: about 90% of the strong CEO candidates we assessed scored high on handling setbacks. #DeliveringReliably It may sound mundane, but the ability to deliver reliable results may be the most powerful of the four core CEO behaviors. In our sample, CEO candidates who scored high on reliability were twice as likely to be picked for the job and 15 times more likely to become high-performing CEOs. Boards and investors love a steady hand, and employees trust leaders they can count on. Leaders who undervalue reliability do so at their peril. Simon, a high-potential executive we were asked to coach, was known as a miracle worker at his company. In a culture where beating plan by 2% counted as success, he delivered 150% of his revenue target. Despite some past stumbles, he was now successfully running the company's largest business unit, its crown jewel. When Simon threw his hat into the ring for CEO, the directors were impressed with his recent standout performance, but they didn't really understand what was behind it, so they doubted it could be repeated. The board chose a "safer" candidate instead, one who had delivered steady, predictable results year after year. Our data back this up. Among strong CEO candidates, 94% scored high on consistently delivering on their commitments. One key to steady performance is setting realistic expectations from the start. In their first few weeks, reliable CEOs resist the temptation to jump straight into execution mode. They dig into the budget and plans and talk to directors, employees, and customers to understand everyone's expectations. At the same time, they quickly assess the business and form their own view, one that's both realistic and aligned with what stakeholders expect. CEOs who score high on reliability are also skilled in other areas. Three-quarters score high on organizing and planning. They build management systems for the business: a smart mix of meetings and metrics, clear accountability, and multiple ways to track performance and correct course. Most important, they surround themselves with strong teams. To be clear, there's no perfect one-size-fits-all mix of behaviors for every CEO. Industry and company context determine which behaviors and skills matter most in a given situation. CEOs in fast-moving industries like tech, for example, need to be especially strong at adapting proactively. In more stable sectors, adaptability matters less. You might wonder: what about basics like integrity? Those are critical for screening out unsuitable candidates, but they don't help you separate the great from the good. In our sample, 100% of underperforming CEOs scored high on integrity, and 97% of them also scored high on work ethic. In the end, our research shows that leadership success doesn't depend on fixed traits or rare gifts beyond ordinary people's reach, and there's no secret formula. It comes down to decisiveness, the ability to engage stakeholders, adaptability, and reliability. There's no universal approach, but focusing on these core behaviors can raise a board's odds of picking the right CEO and a leader's odds of succeeding in the role.

These articles are personal notes, book excerpts, and collected reprints. Figures and events reflect the time of the original publication, are not current information, and do not constitute investment advice.

Share this article
LINEFacebook

Comments

What do you think? Share your experience or questions.

Loading comments…

My reading notes

These notes stay in this browser and are not published. Writing a note also saves the article. Back up or move your notes in My Reading.

Manage my bookmarks and notes →

STAY CURIOUS

Save a good question for your next visit.

Save this article, or follow the Facebook page and RSS feed for additions. Historical articles retain their original publication dates.

Browse All articlesSearch articles and full text →