Management & Organization

How to Stop Agonizing: Three Decision Tools from the Heath Brothers

Share this article
LINEFacebook

Wan Weigang’s Elite Daily Lessons (Dedao; a retelling of the Heath brothers’ Decisive)

Storage information

Bookmarks and reading positions are stored in this browser. Manage and back them up in My Reading.

Collected in Robin Shen’s Field Notes · Content type and attribution are shown above

English version published 2026-11-08 with AI assistance. Attribution, source notes, and verification limits are retained in the text. 中文原文

Reading guide

Wan Weigang, a well-known Chinese science writer, retells three decision-making methods from Chip Heath and Dan Heath’s Decisive (published in Chinese as 成大事者不糾結, “People Who Do Big Things Don’t Agonize”). First, appoint an opposition. When you badly want to do something, confirmation bias sets in and you only hear the positive case. One study found that each extra flattering article about a CEO raised the premium that CEO paid on the next acquisition by 4.8%. Some VC firms assign a designated opponent to every decision, or build a “blue team” whose job is to argue the other side, attacking the idea rather than the person. For personal decisions, you can ask friends to talk some sense into you. Second, look from a distance. A lot of agonizing comes from short-term emotion. Use the 10/10/10 rule: how will you feel about this in ten minutes, ten months, and ten years? Or ask what advice you would give your best friend in the same spot. Research even suggests that thinking in a foreign language makes people more rational, because the extra layer makes it harder for short-term feelings to take over. Third, look at your values. When a tally of costs and benefits can no longer tell you which option is better, you are left with your priorities—career or family, customers or shareholders or employees. There is no right answer, but if you have thought it through in advance, you know how to choose when the tradeoff appears. Values are a guide, not a script, and you still have to revisit them, or you will drift away from why you started.

Key points

  • Appoint an opposition: a blue team whose job is to argue the other side, attacking the idea rather than the person.
  • Each extra flattering article about a CEO raised the acquisition premium by 4.8%.
  • The 10/10/10 rule: how will this look in ten minutes, ten months, and ten years?
  • Ask yourself: if this were my best friend’s choice, what would I tell them?
  • When the numbers no longer help, go back to your core values and priorities—and revisit them often.
Management & Organization thematic illustration
Management & Organization · Thematic illustration · AI generated

Full text — English translation

#Decisive Decisive: How to Make Better Choices in Life and Work, written by Stanford professor Chip Heath with his brother Dan. Kids have a popular way of making a choice. They chant something that sounds like a spell, pointing at the options one after another. When the chant ends, the finger stops, and that is the answer. It is not a scientific method. It does have one virtue: there is no agonizing. You take whatever it lands on, and you go. Real decisions are usually full of agonizing. If you can see at a glance that one option is better than the others, you just pick it. You do not need a decision process. A decision is what you make when several options each have strengths and weaknesses, and none of them is obviously better. So if Decisive is about not agonizing when it counts, how do you actually do that? The brothers offer three methods. ---- 1. Appoint an opposition When we badly want to do something, confirmation bias kicks in. We can hear the arguments in favor, and we simply cannot hear the arguments against. That is often a result of overconfidence. As we discussed last week, CEOs of large companies love to acquire other companies, and they often pay well above the market price. Look at the history of those deals and a lot of them did not end well. Why are they so eager to buy? The Dictator’s Handbook, which we have talked about before, says acquisitions enlarge a CEO’s personal power and do the company little good. The Heath brothers say a large part of it is also CEO arrogance. Think about it. You have a company that is doing well and has been in the press. I have plenty of money, so I do not even compete with you—I just buy you. I make you an offer you cannot refuse. It feels like taking territory. That kind of satisfaction is hard to resist, especially when you are spending the company’s money. One study found that each additional flattering article about a CEO in the mainstream press made that CEO willing to pay a 4.8% higher premium on the next acquisition. Say your company is worth $100 million and a larger company may buy you. You might want to get a reporter to write a glowing piece about that CEO—after which the offer could rise by $4.8 million. That is what happens when you badly want to do something, especially if it also pays you emotionally. You can dig in and refuse to hear otherwise. How do you stop a CEO whose head has been turned by praise? You have to build an opposition. One venture firm’s practice is to assign a designated opponent to every decision. Even if you privately support the investment, your job in the meeting is to come up with every reason not to do it. If you still want to invest after hearing all of those reasons, the decision is more likely to be a sound one. The Heath brothers say that in most companies, formal opposition is missing from the strategy process. It is like a trial with a prosecutor and no defense lawyer. A good method is to name a “blue team” before each decision discussion and give them the job of arguing the other side. The benefit is that because they are opposed by assignment, nobody has to take it personally. You are attacking the idea, not the person. Do ordinary personal decisions need a blue team too? Ask a few friends to argue against you and help reason beat emotion. These days people call it asking someone to talk some sense into you. Asking friends for that kind of pushback has another benefit: a bystander often sees more clearly than you do. 2. Look from a distance A lot of the agony in a hard choice is really a tangle of feelings getting in the way of your judgment. Those feelings are usually short-term. To someone else, or to you after some time has passed, they barely matter. A bystander sees more clearly precisely because they do not have your tangle of feelings, so they can often make a more rational call. You cannot outsource every decision to a bystander, though. The person who knows the situation best is still you. The better approach is to imagine yourself as the bystander. People who are good at this know how to step outside and watch themselves from the side. The Heath brothers describe a particularly useful distancing technique: the 10/10/10 rule. It asks you to look at a problem on three time scales: How will you feel about this decision in 10 minutes? How will you feel in 10 months? How will you feel in 10 years? The 10/10/10 rule is especially good at defeating short-term emotion. The brothers ask you to picture how you will see the choice after ten minutes, ten months, and ten years. That is bystander thinking: stand farther away, and the short-term feelings—fear, nerves—may no longer matter much. Another way to use the same stance is to ask, when you face a hard choice: if this were my best friend’s decision, what would I tell them? There has even been research suggesting that thinking in a second language, a foreign language, helps people make better decisions. Probably because a foreign language puts an extra layer between you and the feeling, and you are less fluent at expressing short-term emotion. That, too, is a form of looking from a distance. If you still cannot decide, there is a third method. 3. Look at your values The first two methods are about letting reason beat emotion, so you can weigh the tradeoffs as objectively as you can. But any analysis has a limit. You may still end up in a place where adding up costs and benefits cannot tell you which option is better. That is when you have to look at your values. What “values” means here is the priorities you have set—what you think matters, and what you think does not. If you cannot have both, is career success more important to you, or a happy family? There is no correct answer. It is a personal choice. You can pick a moral orientation the way you pick an alignment in Dungeons & Dragons. That is a kind of values statement. You can want to be a lawless hero, or a law-abiding person looking out for yourself. Either is fine. Once you have a position, choices get easier. As a company, do you think customer satisfaction matters most, or shareholder satisfaction, or employee satisfaction? Those three often travel together, but sometimes they conflict. If customers come first, you may earn a little less and serve more people. If shareholders come first, you push profit as far as it will go. If employees come first, you might end up like United Airlines, dragging a passenger off a plane to free a seat for crew. If the founder has already told employees what the values are, they know how to choose when they hit a tradeoff. In the end, values are something each person chooses. Nobody can force them on you, and you do not have to stick with a choice forever. Values are a guide. They are not empty words, though. They can actually steer a decision. The Heath brothers say that as people get into the work, they often forget their own priorities and drift with the current. The better habit is to revisit your core values from time to time. Staying true to why you started is harder than it sounds. ---- In short 1. Turn “listen to both sides” into a process, and require specific reasons for the opposing case. 2. Get past short-term emotion, and try to look at the problem from farther away. 3. If a tally of costs and benefits can no longer tell you which option is better, ask what your core values are. #Dedao #EliteDailyLessons

These articles are personal notes, book excerpts, and collected reprints. Figures and events reflect the time of the original publication, are not current information, and do not constitute investment advice.

Share this article
LINEFacebook

Comments

What do you think? Share your experience or questions.

Loading comments…

My reading notes

These notes stay in this browser and are not published. Writing a note also saves the article. Back up or move your notes in My Reading.

Manage my bookmarks and notes →

STAY CURIOUS

Save a good question for your next visit.

Save this article, or follow the Facebook page and RSS feed for additions. Historical articles retain their original publication dates.

Browse All articlesSearch articles and full text →