English version published 2026-11-08 with AI assistance. Attribution, source notes, and verification limits are retained in the text. 中文原文
Full text — English translation
Fact-check notes (2026-10-29):
1. Source: The Venture Mindset by Ilya Strebulaev and Alex Dang. The Chinese edition (Sun Color Culture) published an excerpt titled "A Small Piggy Bank, a Big Winner's Curse" that matches the piggy-bank auction story here. The post didn't credit the source; it's a repost of a different Chinese version, worded slightly differently from the Sun Color excerpt. Source:
https://www.suncolor.com.tw/Article.aspx?id=1638
2. The post says the experimenters ran it "several hundred times"; the Sun Color excerpt says "hundreds of times." The post text is left as is; this note takes precedence.
3. The classic paper on the winner's curse is Richard H. Thaler's "Anomalies: The Winner's Curse," published in the Journal of Economic Perspectives in 1988, which uses bidding on a jar of coins to show the same effect. Source:
https://doi.org/10.1257/jep.2.1.191
----
The winner's curse: when winning means losing
Here's an experiment built around auctioning off a piggy bank. How much money is in the piggy bank (see photo)? Participants bid on it.
First, participants get a few minutes to think while the experimenters watch how they research and plan their bids. Some study the piggy bank closely. Some pick it up to feel its weight, then look up how much a penny weighs. Some take photos of it. Others pull up the calculator on their phones and start crunching numbers.
Then it's auction time. The rules: each participant makes a bid based on how much they think is in the piggy bank, writes it on a piece of paper, and the highest bid wins.
Say the piggy bank holds 3,000 pennies, or $30, and you bid $20. If anyone bids more than $20, you lose. If you bid $20 and everyone else bids less, you win. You pay us $20 and walk away with the $30 inside, a $10 profit. But if you bid $40 and everyone else bids less, you "win" at a $10 loss: you still take home $30, but you pay us $40.
If you bid more than what's in the piggy bank, you win the game and lose at the same time.
Once everyone has written down a bid, things get interesting. We ask everyone to hold their bids in the air. With 30 people waving papers over their heads, the room gets tense. Then we tell people who bid $10 or less to lower their hands, then $15, then $20... $50... $100. As more hands drop, people start looking around in surprise.
Some people's estimates were far below those still holding their hands up. In the end only one person is left with his hand in the air, and his paper reads a big "125."
He's the winner, and everyone cheers. But did he really win? The piggy bank held just $12.74. In other words, this gentleman in silver-rimmed glasses overpaid by $112.26.
He won the auction, but in winning, he lost.
The experimenters have run this hundreds of times and have never once lost money on it. In any group of thirty students or senior executives, someone always bids more than what's in the piggy bank. To win, you have to outbid everyone else, but the thrill of victory doesn't last long once the number is revealed.
This is called the winner's curse. Uncertainty plays a big role. Every participant has to estimate how much is in the piggy bank. Like evaluating a new idea, those estimates rest on assumptions, so they can't be perfectly accurate. Valuation isn't easy. Some guesses come in far below the real value, others far above.
The winner's curse is everywhere, and it plays a big role in venture capital. In VC, the winner's curse is tightly linked to FOMO, and FOMO makes it worse. When investors consider putting in a term sheet, they often worry about being outbid by a more generous competitor. Should they raise their offer so they don't miss the next Amazon, Microsoft, or Facebook? If they don't bid aggressively, they might miss a great investment forever. Startups are like piggy banks, except their true value stays unknown for a long time. VCs try hard to estimate a company's potential, but when they're afraid of losing the deal, they can end up paying far too much.
Naturally, the more anxious investors are, the more likely they are to overvalue a startup. The hotter the venture market, the stronger the FOMO, and the stronger the winner's curse. Plenty of high-profile investments that blew up were the result of giving in to FOMO: FTX's sudden rise and even faster collapse in 2022, WeWork's boom and bust, or Chinese bike-sharing startup ofo. At its peak, ofo raised more than $2 billion from investors. (Robin: Giant, the Taiwanese bike maker, is only worth about NT$46 billion today, and ofo's founder once bragged about buying Giant.) But it soon burst like an overinflated tire, leaving piles of abandoned bikes on street corners. FOMO is a common phenomenon in venture.
In the piggy-bank auction, the winner's curse also gets worse as the number of bidders grows. Win in a room of more than 100 bidders and you'll lose your shirt. It also gets worse when the time to bid is short. Give participants half an hour to work it out carefully, and nobody bids $125 for a piggy bank with $12.74 in coins.
When time is tight and competition is fierce, it's easy to get emotional. Psychologically, we tend to confuse winning the auction with actually winning. We're afraid of missing a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, so we can panic and make irrational decisions. For any deal that looks like a piggy-bank auction, the best response is to step back and take a harder look at all the information available.
#MoneyMerchants
-----
Robin: "VCs need to watch out for the winner's curse. Flip it around, and founders can think about how to use it: how to create a sense of urgency and an atmosphere of competitive pressure. Then again, VCs are pretty sharp too."
Editor's note: The figure in Robin's parenthetical, that Giant is "only worth about NT$46 billion today," has not been verified as of the post date, 2025-06-04. On the claim that "ofo's founder once bragged about buying Giant": June 2017 reports traced the talk of ofo acquiring Giant to remarks by Cheng Wei, an ofo board member and CEO of Didi Chuxing, at a panel discussion. Giant publicly called the report a rumor. Sources:
https://news.tvbs.com.tw/politics/733073 https://www.bicycleretailer.com/international/2017/06/05/giant-shoots-down-sales-rumor-traced-bike-share-moguls-remarkThese articles are personal notes, book excerpts, and collected reprints. Figures and events reflect the time of the original publication, are not current information, and do not constitute investment advice.
Comments
What do you think? Share your experience or questions.
Sign in to comment, reply or like. Sign in / Sign up
Loading comments…