Fact-check note (2026-10-28):
1. Title, author, translator, and publication details: Bo Burlingham, Small Giants (Chinese edition translated by Wu Yu, published by Good Morning Press, May 10, 2017). The post itself only included a link to buy the book, without the author or translator. Source:
https://www.books.com.tw/products/0010750055
Translation note: The English original of this preface (Small Giants: Companies That Choose to Be Great Instead of Big, 10th anniversary edition) wasn’t available to us, so the text below is translated from the Chinese edition. Wording, including quotes from the entrepreneurs, may differ from Burlingham’s original.
----
If you’re interested in the question of scale,
this book is worth a read too.
---
Preface: Who Says a Business Has to Grow?
The stories of 14 “small giants” that are outstanding by any measure, and chose not to get big
In 2003 I noticed something unusual in the business world: companies that didn’t want to be big. They wanted to be great. When an attractive chance to grow and expand came along, they turned it down, because they had something bigger in mind.
I didn’t yet call them “small giants.” Honestly, I wasn’t even sure they added up to a phenomenon. The one case I was sure of was Zingerman’s Community of Business, which Inc. had run as a cover story. The Ann Arbor, Michigan, deli had passed on a big opportunity to expand across the country. Instead, it decided to stay local and start new businesses there. The owners realized they’d created something unique and special in Ann Arbor, and they wanted to recreate that spirit locally under new brands rather than plant flags in other cities. It was the most interesting company I’d ever covered, and it made me wonder: were there other companies like it, ones that would rather stay put than expand?
I started out just curious. Then I kept finding more and more of them. I began to suspect that those of us who’d spent years watching the business world had missed something important. We usually sorted companies into three buckets: big companies, growth companies, and small businesses. The companies in front of me didn’t fit. Some were small, some were large. Some were growing (most were, actually, in very different ways), and some had chosen not to grow at all, or were deliberately keeping their business from getting too big.
Not grow? Then what’s the point?
Set growth and size aside, though, and these companies had a lot in common. First, each was working to be the best at what it did, and each had an excellent reputation. Obviously, companies that good could have raised plenty of capital and grown fast—buying other companies or going after bigger markets, the way big companies do. Instead they chose not to chase revenue growth or expansion. They had other goals that mattered more to them than being big and growing fast. To pursue those goals, they stayed private, with ownership mostly in the hands of one person or a small group of like-minded partners—and employees.
I suspect that’s exactly why we overlooked them for so long. We rarely pay attention to private companies, especially small ones. Our understanding of business—of commerce itself—is shaped largely by public companies.
But public companies are only a small slice of all businesses, and fast-growing tech companies are a tiny slice of that. Yet nearly every best-selling business book, from Iacocca to In Search of Excellence to Good to Great, is about what big companies, or companies trying hard to get big, are doing. Same with most business pages and business magazines, not to mention TV, radio, and the case studies taught in business schools.
Over time we started treating the slogans of big companies as gospel. People like to say a business must grow or die. For a lot of public companies and tech startups, that’s true. Their investors expect, even demand, continuous growth in revenue, profit, and market share, and the moment growth stops, they sell. But thousands of private companies rarely grow much, some don’t grow at all, and they don’t die. They do just fine.
Jack Welch, the former CEO of General Electric, famously said he only wanted to be in businesses that were No. 1 or No. 2 in their markets. Because Welch was so well known, and GE’s stock did so well on his watch, the line got repeated endlessly. Later people noticed that GE itself didn’t follow the rule—and that thousands of small and midsize companies that were neither No. 1 nor No. 2 were doing just fine.
Get real—you don’t run a public company
Then there’s the idea that when a business is doing well, it should move on to “the next level.” What does that mean? Most people assume it has to do with revenue growth (nobody sets “shrinking sales” as a next-level goal), and the next level should obviously be bigger. For a public company, that may or may not be right. For most private companies, it’s flat wrong.
The biggest myth for many business owners is the idea of “shareholder value.” For a public company, shareholder value has a precise meaning: legally and ethically, the company is obligated to deliver the best financial return it can to shareholders. That’s the deal. You took their money, so you give them what they want, and what people who buy publicly traded stock want is a strong return. That relationship is natural and logical, so we all assume every business should work that way.
But that assumption ignores an equally obvious fact: what serves shareholders depends on who the shareholders are.
The shareholders in this book are entrepreneurs who truly own their businesses. Beyond financial goals, they have nonfinancial goals that matter more to them. That doesn’t mean they don’t want to make money. It means making more money isn’t their only goal, and maybe not even their most important one.
What they care about more is being the best at what they do, creating a great place to work, giving customers great service, building close relationships with suppliers, contributing to the communities where they live and work, and finding a good way to live their lives. They’ve also learned that to do all that, they need to own and control their companies, and many go the opposite way from public companies: they put strict limits on how much and how fast they grow. The wealth they create is substantial, but it comes as a byproduct of succeeding at other things.
I thought these companies deserved a name, but I didn’t come up with one until after I’d finished the book. Jay Goltz, one of the entrepreneurs I interviewed, suggested calling them “small giants.” I liked it.
Let me explain how I picked them.
Outstanding entrepreneurs who deliberately keep a low profile
From the start I knew I needed selection criteria. First, I couldn’t use financial performance. One perk of staying private is that you don’t have to share your numbers with anyone but the tax authorities, your bank, and your investors (if you have any). Many private-company owners go to great lengths to keep their financials confidential. Few produce audited financial statements, and even fewer make them public. Private companies also come in more forms than public ones and have more flexibility in how they handle money, and depending on their legal structure—a C corporation, an S corporation, a partnership—they’re taxed differently and use cash differently. So while it isn’t impossible, it’s hard to compare private companies’ financials objectively, and even when you can get the information, it often doesn’t tell you much.
Beyond the numbers, there’s visibility. Most private companies aren’t well known. They may get the occasional moment in the spotlight—an award, a big milestone, an important innovation, a big ad campaign—but they rarely have the name recognition of 3M, American Express, Wal-Mart, Disney, McDonald’s, or any other household-name corporation. When a private company does get noticed, it’s usually for its great products or services, not for being a great company. In other words, I couldn’t just run a poll asking people to name the “most admired companies.”
But I knew exactly what kind of company I was looking for: an outstanding private company that was willing to give up revenue or expansion when necessary to pursue other, more important goals.
By “outstanding,” I mean a company with a distinctive vision and business model that clearly sets it apart from others in its industry. Over my years as editor-at-large and writer at Inc., I’d already come across several companies that met that bar, and I was confident more digging would turn up more. I cast as wide a net as I could, asking everyone I knew to recommend companies. I searched online and dug through newspaper and magazine databases for possible candidates.
Once I had a decent list, I did a first cut to pick out the ones most likely to fit. Then I started interviewing, narrowing the list further and zeroing in on what really made these companies different. Inevitably, deciding which companies qualified involved some subjectivity. To keep that to a minimum, I added a few more criteria along the way:
1. I limited the field to companies that had had the chance to grow fast, scale up, go public, or sell to a bigger company, but whose founders and leaders deliberately chose not to.
2. I focused on companies that were respected and imitated by peers and competitors.
3. They had to be outstanding, as confirmed by independent outside observers—third parties who agreed the company deserved recognition.
Next came size. “Big” and “small” are relative, and highly subjective. To a family business doing $200,000 a year, a company with six employees and $2 million in sales is huge. The mainstream media, though, usually treats any company with less than $300 million in annual revenue as small. I remember a BusinessWeek article describing a company with $104 million in annual sales as “tiny”—I’ll come back to that company later.
How many people work at your company? Is it still on a human scale?
I had to decide how to think about size. As the research went on, I realized that for the purposes of this book, what mattered wasn’t revenue. It was headcount. I was looking for companies that had stayed on a human scale: everyone knows everyone, the CEO personally interviews new hires, and employees feel closely connected to the company.
That criterion immediately ruled out some private companies, such as the big ones on the Forbes list, all of which have more than $1 billion in annual sales. But I wasn’t sure how many employees a company could have and still be on a human scale. I also had to consider that some companies might be too small to count as part of the phenomenon. In the end I included a few companies that represent the outer limits of the phenomenon in size, to see what we could learn from them.
Besides companies that were too big or too small, I left out a few types that might otherwise have qualified. One was lifestyle businesses—companies whose only goal is to give the owner a comfortable life outside work. Unless they change their reason for existing, they can only grow so much; they don’t have many choices. I also cut franchisees, since their vision comes from another owner, the franchisor, which has already chosen a different way to grow. Luxury businesses aimed at the high end weren’t on my list either, since staying small is core to their strategy. Their model has stood the test of time, but it’s not what I was looking for. I was looking for companies that broke with convention and succeeded by going their own way. Finally, I cut the traditional mom-and-pop business—the small business set up mainly to give the family members who own it a job. Some do well, but by my standards they weren’t outstanding.
Even with all those limits, I quickly found far more companies that fit than I could fit in one book. The longer I looked, the more I found. They were in every corner of the country and nearly every industry—retailers, wholesalers, manufacturers, service companies, professional services firms, arts businesses. A few were somewhat known for popular consumer products; most were known, if at all, for working with or competing against famous companies.
Having that many candidates let me choose for both depth and breadth, picking companies that represented the phenomenon I wanted to describe. On one hand, I wanted variety in size, age, location, and type of business. On the other, I wanted companies run by a certain kind of owner: leaders who had deliberately chosen not to go public, deliberately limited their growth, and in return gained the freedom to run their businesses as they saw fit—and who made full use of that freedom. That, to me, is the real reward of owning a business. If you’re determined to grow as much as possible, or bring in outside capital, or take the company public, you give that freedom up.
Is it worth becoming a slave to your company just to go public?
If you run a public company or one backed by venture capital, you become a servant of the business, with an endless list of demands to meet. You’re constantly recruiting, selling, training, negotiating, shaking hands, cajoling, soothing, warning, pleading, persuading—it never ends. Maybe you find that exciting, but you won’t have time for much else, let alone time to think hard about what more you want for your company or your life. Leaders who choose to stay private, keep ownership in a few hands, and put other goals ahead of growth get two big rewards: control and time. Both matter as much as freedom itself—or more precisely, the chance to be free.
In the end I picked fourteen companies that, to my mind, represent the two ends of the phenomenon. The smallest was Selima Inc., a six-year-old fashion design and dressmaking business in Miami Beach with two employees. The largest was O.C. Tanner Co., a 79-year-old Salt Lake City company with 1,900 employees and $350 million in annual sales, which helps clients design employee recognition programs and makes service awards. It made the medals for the 2002 Winter Olympics.
Here are the fourteen companies:
· Anchor Brewing, San Francisco: America’s first microbrewery.
· CitiStorage Inc., Brooklyn, New York: the first independent records-storage company in the U.S.
· Clif Bar Inc., Berkeley, California: a leading brand of natural and organic energy bars and nutrition foods.
· ECCO, Boise, Idaho: a leading maker of backup alarms and amber warning lights for commercial vehicles.
· Hammerhead Productions, Studio City, California: a computer special-effects shop for the movie industry.
· O.C. Tanner Co., Salt Lake City, Utah: a top provider of employee recognition and service awards.
· Reell Precision Manufacturing, St. Paul, Minnesota: designer and manufacturer of motion-control products, including the hinges in laptop computers.
· Rhythm & Hues Studios, Los Angeles: computer-animated characters and visual effects; it won an Oscar for Babe.
· Righteous Babe Records, Buffalo, New York: founded by singer-songwriter Ani DiFranco.
· Selima Inc., Miami Beach, Florida: designs and makes custom clothing for individual clients.
· The Goltz Group, Chicago, Illinois: includes Artists’ Frame Service, the best-known independent frame shop in the country.
· Union Square Hospitality Group, New York City: founded by the renowned restaurateur Danny Meyer.
· W.L. Butler Construction, Redwood City, California: a general contractor specializing in commercial projects.
· Zingerman’s Community of Business, Ann Arbor, Michigan: includes the world-famous Zingerman’s Delicatessen and seven other food-related businesses.
The youngest was Hammerhead Productions, founded in 1994; the oldest was O.C. Tanner, founded in 1927. All had been around long enough to see their share of ups and downs. All but one were consistently profitable, some very much so. The exception was Rhythm & Hues, partly because of how it chose to use its cash. (Some strong companies declined to be interviewed. Their owners said flatly that they didn’t want outsiders to know how they run their businesses.)
Everyone has a reason for starting a business. What’s yours?
The leaders of these fourteen companies came from very different backgrounds and had very different personalities and temperaments, and each had a distinctive path before the business took off.
Jay Goltz of the Goltz Group was a born entrepreneur, a wunderkind whom Forbes named an entrepreneurial whiz kid in his early twenties. As an adult his goal was to make a lot of money, and he chased growth aggressively—until one day he realized he didn’t want to live that way anymore.
Singer-songwriter Ani DiFranco wowed the major labels, which saw early on that she had star potential. She turned every one of them down and started Righteous Babe Records herself, because she simply didn’t want to sign with a big company.
Jim Thompson had been one of the best accountants at Boise Cascade (which later sold ECCO) when two heart attacks made him rethink how he approached his career.
Bill Butler lived in a small California community when he started Butler; eighteen years in, he’d built up a solid roster of clients.
Dan Chuba and his three partners all came from big special-effects houses. They started Hammerhead specifically to stay small, so each of them would have time to take on their own projects.
John Hughes and his partners left Robert Abel and Associates, Hollywood’s first computer-graphics company, to start Rhythm & Hues. Their goal was to create “an environment where people enjoy their work, treat one another fairly and honestly, and respect each other.”
Selima Stavola, an Iraqi Jew, grew up in Baghdad. After World War II she immigrated to New York with her husband, an army officer, and started designing clothes to help support the family. Fashion executives and investors loved her work and saw her as the next Christian Dior or Coco Chanel.
Norm Brodsky of CitiStorage watched an earlier company of his grow from zero to $120 million in sales in just eight years, then crash from that peak and go bankrupt. That forced him to think hard about how and why he’d become so obsessed with fast growth.
Dale Merrick, Bob Wahlstedt, and Lee Johnson, all refugees from 3M, founded Reell Precision Manufacturing to build a business that supported a balance between work and family life. It ended up as one of the most democratic companies in the world.
Different as they were, these entrepreneurs had things in common. Each had goals that mattered more than revenue growth and expansion, and each had thought them through clearly and held them with confidence. “You make more money by choosing the right things to say no to than by choosing the right things to say yes to,” said Danny Meyer, founder of Union Square Hospitality Group. “I mean it, because I haven’t made less money or sacrificed quality because of it.”
Does your company have… that certain something?
As I said, I was hoping the people I interviewed would help me figure out what made these companies so different. To their credit, they showed me that these companies really did have something many others lack, and they knew what it was. So did people who’d dealt with them.
Norm Brodsky of CitiStorage told me about inviting Richard Reese, chairman and CEO of Iron Mountain, to visit. Iron Mountain was the largest records-storage company in the country, with more than $2 billion in annual sales. Reese had heard Brodsky speak at an industry conference and was impressed, so Brodsky invited him to come see how CitiStorage worked, and Reese said yes on the spot. On the appointed day, Reese came to CitiStorage in Brooklyn, across the East River, and for the next four or five hours Brodsky showed him around and introduced him to every employee. That day Brodsky’s wife, Elaine, the vice president of human resources and a central figure in the company, happened to be teaching a customer-service class. Brodsky asked Reese if he’d like to sit in. Employees role-played different customer-service situations, and Reese was so absorbed he forgot he had somewhere else to be.
As he was leaving, Reese said to Brodsky, “You’ve built a remarkable company. I wish we could be like you.”
“What do you mean?” Brodsky asked.
“The way you run your business,” Reese said. “It’s fantastic. After touring your company and talking to your people, I feel like I should take all this back to my company, but I know we can’t do it.”
“I don’t get it,” Brodsky said. “Why can’t you?”
“It’s hard once you get big,” Reese said. “Maybe you should come visit us and you’ll see what I mean.” Brodsky took it as a compliment to CitiStorage and passed it along to his people.
I felt about the companies on my list the way Reese felt about CitiStorage. They had a quality that was real and inspiring, but hard to define. When I visited, I could feel it. I could see it on the bulletin boards and on people’s faces. I could hear it in how they talked. I could sense it in how they dealt with coworkers, customers, and strangers. But I also found it elusive.
It reminded me of how it felt dealing with hot companies back when they were growing fast—Apple Computer, Fidelity Investments, People Express Airlines, Ben & Jerry’s, Patagonia, the Body Shop, even Inc. magazine. They were excited, happy, expectant. They felt like part of a movement, with a sense of purpose and direction about where they were going. I think that’s what happens when people find themselves completely in sync with their market, the world, and everyone around them—everything seems to be going right.
Most of the companies I knew eventually lost that quality. The companies I was now looking for were all working hard to keep it.
Give your company time to develop a soul
So what is it? Danny Meyer of Union Square Hospitality Group says a business has to have a soul. He believes soul is what makes a company great—what makes it worth existing at all.
“I’m not interested in a business without a soul,” he said. And soul comes from the relationships you build along the way. “If you can’t actively build meaningful dialogues with your employees, customers, community, suppliers, and investors, the business has no soul. When you start a business, your job as the entrepreneur is to tell people, ‘Here’s what I believe in. Here’s why I started this. Here’s my point of view.’ At first it may be just the entrepreneur’s idea, but slowly it becomes a dialogue, and eventually a real conversation. It’s like breaking in a baseball glove. You can’t wait for the glove to get comfortable; you have to use it to make it comfortable. You have to give every new business enough time to settle in. If you move on to the next thing too fast, the business never develops its own soul. Think about a new restaurant on opening night—everyone’s rushing to get in, but something feels missing, because it doesn’t have a soul yet. That takes time, and you have to keep working at it.”
The idea of a company’s soul helps explain how this quality develops. But I think Gary Erickson of Clif Bar defined it even more clearly. He’d been thinking a lot about what he wanted Clif Bar to be. At a trade show in the fall of 2000, a well-known consumer-products marketer came by, raved about the Clif Bar booth, and pointed to a competitor’s booth that Clif had completely outshone. “They’ve lost their mojo,” the man said. From then on, mojo became Erickson’s watchword.
I think mojo is exactly the mysterious quality I saw at Clif Bar, CitiStorage, Union Square Hospitality, and the others. Take your eye off it and you can lose it. In his thought-provoking book Raising the Bar, Erickson writes that Clif’s mojo affected “the brand, the products, and the way we were in the world, and set us apart. I finally understood that mojo is an elusive quality that has to be carefully protected.” After hearing that remark at the trade show, he asked his employees to pick a company that once had mojo and lost it, and to explain why. He got a lot of thoughtful answers: some companies lost their creativity as they kept growing, some drifted away from their customers, some became “too commercial,” some fixated on cutting costs, some neglected their community, some couldn’t hold on to their culture, and some grew too big, too fast.
Then Erickson asked his colleagues whether Clif Bar had mojo. If so, what kind, and how could they strengthen it or use it? He collected all the answers in a binder and kept it on display in the office for a long time. Reading through them, he saw three things clearly:
1. Most people know instinctively what mojo is. 2. They have all kinds of explanations for how to create it. 3. They tend to define mojo by its effects rather than its causes—or, as one employee put it, “To me, mojo means, ‘Baby, you’ve got an engine running, and the sky’s the limit.’”
Ten years later, do they still have their mojo?
What did these companies do that ultimately gave them their mojo? Probably a lot of things came together. I decided one way to narrow it down was to look for what the companies I believed had mojo had in common.
First, unlike most entrepreneurs, these founders and leaders considered a wide range of options when deciding what kind of company to build. Unconstrained by standard practice, they questioned their industry’s definition of success, imagined what was possible, and didn’t limit themselves to the familiar choices.
Second, these leaders chose an unconventional path that most successful companies hadn’t taken and wouldn’t want to, and they withstood the heavy pressure that came with it. They kept control, or took it back. They kept searching for the company’s soul, turned down plenty of well-meant advice, chose their own way, and built businesses they were willing to devote their lives to, instead of meekly accepting a form of company shaped by outside forces.
Third, each company had a deep relationship with its city, town, or state—one that went beyond “giving back.” Of course that was part of it, and all of them were model corporate citizens. But the relationship ran both ways: the community helped shape the company’s character, and the company played a key role in the life of the community.
Fourth, they put special weight on close relationships with customers and suppliers—through personal contact, one-on-one interaction, and mutual commitment to keeping promises. The leaders set the example. They made themselves accessible and worked to keep those relationships human. Customers responded with supportive emails; suppliers responded with good service. The result was a sense of community and shared purpose among the company, its suppliers, and its customers. That kind of intimacy is something big companies can’t achieve, simply because they’re too big.
Fifth, I was surprised to find that these companies also created extraordinarily close-knit workplaces. In fact, they were like small, fully functioning societies, working to meet their employees’ needs as human beings: creative, emotional, spiritual, and social as well as economic. Herb Kelleher of Southwest Airlines once observed that Southwest’s famously lively culture was built on the principle of attending to all of people’s needs, not just their work needs. That’s what the companies I was looking for were doing. They created workplaces where employees felt that everything they needed in life was looked after. These leaders treated their people the way they believed people should be treated: with respect, dignity, integrity, fairness, kindness, and generosity. In that sense, these companies were the ultimate expression of a business as a social institution.
Sixth, the companies had corporate structures and governance that were strikingly different from what most people imagine. Because they were private, they had a lot of freedom to build their own management systems and methods, and several did just that. Zingerman’s created its own community of businesses, including a training company, ZingTrain, that teaches the Zingerman’s way of doing business. Hammerhead Productions invented its own accordion-style organization, expanding when it started a new project and contracting when the work wound down. Reell Precision Manufacturing was the most democratic company I’ve ever seen. It had two CEOs and a very unusual structure, and it worked. Several others turned themselves into educational institutions, teaching employees the finance, service, and leadership skills they needed to succeed in business.
Finally, I noticed that these leaders were passionate about what their companies did. They loved their businesses, whether the product was music, safety lights, food, special effects, torque hinges, beer, records storage, construction, energy bars, or fashion. They were consummate businesspeople, but they weren’t professional managers. In fact, they were the opposite. They had deep emotional connections to their businesses, their employees, their customers, and their suppliers—the kind of emotional attachment that professional managers are often taught to avoid.
This book covers all of those observations. In this tenth-anniversary edition, I’ve revised the original text and followed up on how these companies have done over the past ten years. We’ll look at the choices these companies made, how they made them, and how they resisted the forces pulling them in another direction. Then we’ll examine what these companies have in common, including three that built extraordinarily close relationships with their communities, customers, suppliers, and employees. When a company grows too fast, gets too big, or spreads too wide, that kind of intimacy isn’t impossible, but it’s very hard. We’ll also take a close look at the unique structures and operating models some of these companies use to reach their goals.
Then comes a new chapter, one I would have included in the first edition if I’d been able to get the data I needed. It’s about numbers: what financial traits do these small giants share that let them survive over the long haul? I’ll also take on succession—can a company like this last more than a generation, and if so, how? Finally, we’ll see what’s happened to the small giants in the ten years since Small Giants first came out.
But first, let’s look at how each small giant took that crucial first step. For Fritz Maytag of Anchor Brewing, that step came in 1992, when he realized something no one had ever told him: his company didn’t have to keep growing and growing. It didn’t have to get bigger. It didn’t have to become impersonal.
He had a choice.
https://www.books.com.tw/products/0010750055
Comments
What do you think? Share your experience or questions.
Sign in to comment, reply or like. Sign in / Sign up
Loading comments…