Entrepreneurship & Strategy

Three PayPal Principles

Share this article
LINEFacebook

Compiled from the original post (see notes for sources and verification limits)

Storage information

Bookmarks and reading positions are stored in this browser. Manage and back them up in My Reading.

Collected in Robin Shen’s Field Notes · Content type and attribution are shown above

English version published 2026-11-08 with AI assistance. Attribution, source notes, and verification limits are retained in the text. 中文原文

Reading guide

Move fast, focus on the hardest important problem, and put the company ahead of personal conflict. This account of PayPal's early years uses hiring, management, and leadership disputes to illustrate those three ideas. Its anecdotes are not all independently verified, and hiring through shared networks does not establish that demographic diversity hurts startups.

Key points

  • The hiring story emphasizes shared backgrounds as a way to reduce communication costs and speed up early execution, not as proof against demographic diversity.
  • Give each person one core task so easier work cannot crowd out the hardest, most valuable problem.
  • Assess the single most valuable contribution an employee makes, rather than spreading attention across many priorities.
  • Keep the company's interests above personal disagreements, including when leadership roles change.
Entrepreneurship & Strategy thematic illustration
Entrepreneurship & Strategy · Thematic illustration · AI generated

Full text — English translation

Sources and verification limits (2026-11-02): This post is labeled as coming from Zhang Xiaoyu's classic business case course on the Dedao app; the full course wasn't available. Interview accounts of hiring through personal networks don't prove that gender or racial diversity hurts startups. The Musk survey story, the probability, the domain price, the reinvestment of sale proceeds, and other figures and stories haven't been independently verified one by one. SEC departure filings support only some of the dates of service and can't vouch for the other anecdotes. The original post doesn't link to a copy of the same text that could be checked directly. ---- Three ideas behind PayPal's rapid growth. | "Harmful" diversity The first idea is about hiring. PayPal had a counterintuitive principle for early hiring: in a startup's early days, skip diversity. The more alike your hires are, the better. Lots of companies today, especially internet companies, emphasize workforce diversity: gender, race, geography, educational background, and more. The common belief is that the more diverse your people, the more innovative the company and the better the business. PayPal did the opposite. Its view was that early on, a startup shouldn't worry about political correctness or innovation capacity. Everything should serve speed. So when building the team, you should hire lots of people with backgrounds, ways of thinking, and even lifestyles similar to your own. That way the company doesn't burn time debating decisions big and small, like which programming language to use, which internal communication tool is best, or even where the office should be. Once a team starts spending its time on debates like that, a startup loses its advantage of being small, fast, and nimble. How far did PayPal take this? Its first 10 engineers all graduated from UIUC, the University of Illinois, and had taken almost the same courses. Its first five non-technical hires all came from Peter Thiel's Stanford network. Those shared backgrounds kept communication costs extremely low, which let PayPal grow very fast early on. As the saying goes, "If you want to go fast, go alone. If you want to go far, go together." PayPal's early team-building approach was about making a small team act like one person, so it could move and think fast. | Extreme focus The second idea is a management philosophy Peter Thiel used as PayPal's CEO. Internally it was called "extreme manager focus." Thiel said that when managing a company, people often ask questions like "What are your top five priorities this week?" or "What are the three most important metrics for measuring your results this quarter?" Thiel thought that approach was wrong. The moment you start ranking your priorities, your attention gets divided. So he required PayPal's managers and employees to focus on only one thing at a time. And he was absolute about it. If any employee came to him to discuss something other than their one core task, Thiel would refuse to talk about it until that core task was done. At year-end reviews, Thiel also required PayPal employees to write down their "single most valuable contribution to the company." The key: they could write only one. Here's how Thiel explained it. People are naturally inclined to avoid challenges and hard problems. Say you have two tasks. One is very hard, with no clear answer, but solving it would give the company a huge boost. The other has a fairly clear answer and would help the company somewhat, but not nearly as much. People tend to go for the problem with the clear answer first. Once that's done, they find another easy problem, and the really hard but really important problem gets shelved. But what if you have only one task? Then you'll throw everything at it, because there's nowhere to hide. Thiel put it this way: if a company keeps ignoring the 95-out-of-100-difficulty problems and keeps solving the 80- or 85-level ones, it will end up as a 70- or 80-point company. This extreme-focus approach not only lets people pour all their energy into getting the job done, it also pushes the company to keep outdoing itself and reaching higher. It laid a solid foundation for PayPal's success. | Big-picture thinking and generosity The last story is about the war between Peter Thiel's and Elon Musk's teams. At the height of the fight between PayPal and X.com, Thiel and Musk chose to merge the two companies, then immediately raised $100 million to keep charging ahead. But in reality the two teams, including Thiel and Musk themselves, clashed on a lot of ideas, and the partnership was far from smooth. Thiel was the first to resign. Shortly after the $100 million round, he clashed with X.com's executives. They thought PayPal should start charging fees, since everyone was burning cash too fast. Thiel believed charging would slow the company down, which would hurt PayPal's growth. The two sides kept clashing over plenty of smaller things too, and in the end, for the good of the company, Thiel decided to resign and leave PayPal. Five months later, history repeated itself. After Thiel resigned, Musk took over as PayPal's CEO. He didn't do much better. First he clashed with the engineering team led by the CTO. It started with PayPal preparing version 2.0 and an argument over which platform to build it on. Over the engineers' objections, Musk decided they would develop on Windows NT. Many of the original PayPal engineers resisted, so progress on the new version was very slow. The other flashpoint was that once Musk took over, he wanted to phase out the PayPal brand and replace it with X.com. Musk reportedly paid $1 million for the domain and thought the name was easy to remember. But PayPal had launched earlier and offered a better experience, so users preferred the PayPal brand. One small sign says it all: the way we say "just Google it" today, eBay users back then would say "PayPal me the money." When a brand goes from noun to verb, it's not far from success. Even so, Musk insisted on replacing the PayPal brand with X.com. It was right around the opening of the Sydney Olympics, and Musk took two weeks off for a belated honeymoon in Sydney with his then-wife. Before leaving, he told the product manager to remove the PayPal brand entirely. PayPal's employees weren't having it. While the boss was away, they ran a user survey. They randomly picked a few thousand users and asked what they thought of the two names. Users agreed with the team: they liked PayPal better, and many said X.com sounded like a porn site. But by sheer coincidence, the few thousand randomly selected users included Elon Musk himself. Given PayPal's user count at the time, the odds were less than 1 in 1,000. Musk, still on his honeymoon, started making furious calls in the middle of the night, demanding to know who was responsible, and ordered the product manager to stop the survey and keep replacing the brand. That turned out to be the last straw. PayPal's product leadership decided to stage a coup and push Musk out. They got people to sign a petition and told the board that if Musk wasn't removed as CEO, they would all resign. After discussions with the board, Musk formally stepped down. And who took over as CEO? Peter Thiel, who had left just five months earlier. He let bygones be bygones and came back to lead the team. Once Thiel was back, he kept the PayPal brand and gradually led the company out of trouble. What's even more worth noting is this: however much Musk and Thiel disagreed, and however much friction there was among executives and employees, they all understood that everything they were doing was for the company's growth and progress. So when Musk left, he didn't make a scene or try to take everyone down with him. He calmly accepted reality. In a later round, Musk even put more of his own money into PayPal, a vote of confidence. Later, when eBay bought PayPal for $1.5 billion, Musk personally made $165 million. He then poured all of it into SpaceX, Tesla, and SolarCity. The PayPal story is another lesson in putting the bigger picture first, and in what it looks like when people can disagree without falling out. Because they had that kind of vision and generosity, Thiel and Musk both went on to become two of the most influential people in Silicon Valley, and good friends. #Dedao #ZhangXiaoyuClassicBusinessCases

These articles are personal notes, book excerpts, and collected reprints. Figures and events reflect the time of the original publication, are not current information, and do not constitute investment advice.

Share this article
LINEFacebook

Comments

What do you think? Share your experience or questions.

Loading comments…

My reading notes

These notes stay in this browser and are not published. Writing a note also saves the article. Back up or move your notes in My Reading.

Manage my bookmarks and notes →

STAY CURIOUS

Save a good question for your next visit.

Save this article, or follow the Facebook page and RSS feed for additions. Historical articles retain their original publication dates.

Browse All articlesSearch articles and full text →