English version published 2026-11-08 with AI assistance. Attribution, source notes, and verification limits are retained in the text. 中文原文
Full text — English translation
How to define a core advantage—the description has to be real and specific
Defining a core advantage is not easy. It cannot stay at the level of abstract thought. It has to be joined to a set of real factors: what customers need, what assets you have, what you like doing, what your partners can do, and what the owners’ personal and financial goals are.
You have to move quickly and describe it concretely, so that the statement you end up with is both true and precise. Unlike other pieces of building a company, this one cannot be changed lightly. Once you settle it, you have to stay with it for the long run.
Changing a core advantage casually creates a great deal of risk; it can wipe out an edge you worked hard to build. Of course, as your understanding of the market, the customer, and your important assets deepens, you can adjust it. Google is a good example. At first Google thought its outstanding search algorithm was the core advantage. What actually succeeded was a new business model, keyword advertising, and then it reached network effects before competitors could move.
---
Is intellectual property or company culture a core advantage?
Companies often treat intellectual property as the core advantage. In reality, how much force IP has as a core advantage depends a great deal on the industry. In healthcare, especially in biotech, a patent is an important factor in whether a biotech startup’s product succeeds. In other industries IP may have some value, but it is hardly a necessary condition for the company to succeed.
Technology is static; markets are alive. The ability to apply a patent often matters more than the patent itself. Of course it is better to have both. A team that is strong at application can keep shipping new products; a company that merely lives off a handful of patents often lacks enough drive to keep building.
---
Is speed of innovation a core advantage?
Some companies are good at driving innovation quickly through process or culture, and they build a market edge that way. Early on they stay tightly focused on the customer and use strong product management and agile development to turn an early lead into an advantage that can keep growing. As the company scales, though, that kind of speed is hard to sustain as a distinctive long-term core advantage, because when smaller companies enter the market they will have a better agility edge and leave you behind on the pace of innovation. So most companies do not win on speed of innovation alone. They treat it as fuel—as protection until the real core advantage is clear.
In other words, every company has to innovate quickly, whether or not that is the core advantage. Without something else serving as the real core, very few companies keep succeeding on rapid innovation alone.
---
Is first-mover advantage a core advantage?
First-mover advantage is a very common mistaken idea of what a core advantage is. It means succeeding merely because you were first in the market. Most first movers, though, end up being overtaken by someone who came later. First-mover advantage by itself does not become a durable core advantage; sometimes it is even a disadvantage.
It can help a company that has already defined a real core advantage to succeed. It is not, by itself, a guarantee that you will win the market. In other words, if all you have is a first-mover position and you cannot turn it into something else—locking in key customers, building positive network effects, hiring the best people in a particular domain—you still cannot count on success.
---
Is locking up a supplier’s exclusive supply a core advantage?
Competitive advantage includes anticipating the various pieces of a solution and then locking up suppliers on an exclusive basis. If a supplier also sells into several different markets, or if you need to buy in volume from a smaller supplier, you can ask for exclusivity in return for agreed timing and minimum-order requirements. Apple has used this kind of tactic, and the high margins it produced gave the company resources and flexibility. That is not Apple’s core advantage, though. Apple’s real core advantage is a culture of pursuing perfection and going beyond what people imagined—values that were realized under Steve Jobs.
As with intellectual property, locking up key suppliers is a good way to keep potential competitors at bay, and you should use it when the situation is right. It is not the company’s core advantage. At most it is an obstacle you place in a competitor’s path. On a competitive field, laying traps to slow rivals down is a tactic. A core advantage, in other words, is the trump card that finally stops every competitor.
----
Once you have defined a core advantage, you have to turn it into a sustainable edge for the future.
Clearly, the first conclusion a team reaches about its core advantage is often wrong. The easy answers are never the real thing. You should put real effort into this question, because getting it right gives the company an enormous advantage.
Defining a core advantage is the first step in a company thinking seriously about itself, and it is quite different from an emphasis on focusing on the customer. A core advantage is what your competitors do not have: the capability that lets you protect yourself and keep building an edge that can grow.
Once it is defined, don’t change it lightly. You should keep reinforcing it. A core advantage that keeps shifting is a bad sign; it suggests you cannot form a capability you can keep developing. When you discover what customers value most, and what you yourself are best at, the core advantage can change.
Defining it is abstract and difficult work. Doing this step well will raise the company’s value a great deal.
#DisciplinedEntrepreneurship
----
Robin: “Most founders’ idea of a core advantage is not a very good answer—especially the startups that treat a patent as the core. Honestly, outside biotech, I don’t think any Taiwanese startup has succeeded because a patent was its core advantage. Plenty of startups instead get absorbed in their own patents, trying to make money from the patent rather than from the underlying business, and that is what keeps the project from moving forward.”
These articles are personal notes, book excerpts, and collected reprints. Figures and events reflect the time of the original publication, are not current information, and do not constitute investment advice.
Comments
What do you think? Share your experience or questions.
Sign in to comment, reply or like. Sign in / Sign up
Loading comments…