Entrepreneurship & Strategy

The Digital Revolution Is Less Disruptive Than It Looks: Four Ways Incumbents Respond

Share this article
LINEFacebook

Robin’s commentary + #DedaoHeadlines (summary of London Business School professor Julian Birkinshaw’s Harvard Business Review article)

Storage information

Bookmarks and reading positions are stored in this browser. Manage and back them up in My Reading.

Collected in Robin Shen’s Field Notes · Content type and attribution are shown above

English version published 2026-11-08 with AI assistance. Attribution, source notes, and verification limits are retained in the text. 中文原文

Reading guide

A Dedao Headlines summary of Julian Birkinshaw's research. Contrary to popular belief, many big companies on the 1995 rankings were still there in 2020; only TMT and retail saw major shake-ups. Incumbents facing disruptors use four strategies: fight head-on, double down, retreat and obstruct, or exit. Robin's take: incumbents rarely succeed when they attack new markets, so startups should pull the giants onto a track the startup created, not try to overtake them on a track the giants already built.

Key points

  • Most incumbents in traditional industries held their ground
  • Each of the four strategies has both successes and failures
  • Startups should pull giants onto a new track, not chase them on the old one
Entrepreneurship & Strategy thematic illustration
Entrepreneurship & Strategy · Thematic illustration · AI generated

Full text — English translation

Fact-check notes (2026-10-30): 1. Source: Julian Birkinshaw, "How Incumbents Survive and Thrive," Harvard Business Review, January–February 2022, and its accompanying chart, "Four Ways to Respond to Disruption." The post is a Chinese summary. This site didn't have access to the full HBR article, so the survival counts and company examples follow the post and haven't been checked one by one. Sources: https://hbr.org/2022/01/how-incumbents-survive-and-thrive https://hbr.org/data-visuals/2022/01/four-ways-to-respond-to-disruption 2. The closing Bezos quote about "what's not going to change" is given here in his original English wording. ---- Robin: "The digital revolution is still playing out. One key point here is that when incumbents go on the offensive into new markets, they don't succeed very often. Professor Clayton Christensen lays this out clearly in The Innovator's Dilemma and his other books. So if you're a startup and you want to win, you have to pull the giants onto a track you created. Don't stay on the track the giants already built and hope to overtake them on a curve." --- The digital revolution is sweeping through everything. The new wave is overturning the old, and every industry is being reshuffled fast. Look globally and it seems the same: tech innovation is surging, new unicorns keep appearing, and they're challenging the old industry leaders. That's our shared sense of this era. But in a Harvard Business Review article, London Business School professor Julian Birkinshaw says that's wrong. It's actually an illusion. In the U.S. and globally, the digital revolution has been far less disruptive than we think. Compare the 1995 and 2020 rankings. Of the 1995 Fortune 500 (U.S.), 198 companies were still on the list in 2020. Of the 1995 Global 500, 164 were still there in 2020. Break it down by industry and only two, technology/media/telecom (TMT) and retail, saw major shake-ups. In most other industries, including energy, chemicals, autos, healthcare, finance, and consumer goods, the top players barely changed over 25 years. The stability is remarkable. Birkinshaw argues that the power of digital disruption has been overhyped. The tech world predicted that digital would threaten every industry, that disruption was accelerating, and that established companies couldn't adapt to the digital age. In hindsight, that didn't happen. Most traditional industry leaders are doing just fine. So how did these companies hold their position against disruptors? Birkinshaw found that incumbents' responses fall along two dimensions, producing four playbooks. One dimension is offense versus defense. The other is staying in the old business versus moving into the new one. Go on offense and move into the new business, and you get the first approach: fight head-on. Think legacy automakers launching EV lines, traditional media launching news websites, or legacy airlines launching low-cost carriers. There are success stories, but overall incumbents can't beat the newcomers in the new business. One reason is that incumbents have a hard time avoiding the "learning trap." Go on offense but stay in the old business, and you get the second approach: double down. Reinforce your existing strengths and widen your moat. Disney, for example, was already feeling pressure from Netflix before 2010, but it didn't rush to build its own streaming service. Instead it doubled down on content, using its massive library to strengthen its hand in negotiations with Netflix. Or take WHSmith, the British bookstore chain. When Amazon came after it in the early 2000s, it didn't try to build its own online bookstore like other chains did. It doubled down on retail, opening stores in high-traffic airports and train stations, and kept growing profits steadily. Play defense and hold the old business, and you get the third approach: retreat and obstruct. Merge to reduce competition, and find every way to put regulatory obstacles in disruptors' path and raise barriers to entry. For instance, hotel giants have pushed governments to impose more regulation and restrictions on Airbnb. Interestingly, when companies retreat, they often pretend to be fighting head-on or doubling down while quietly pulling back. Many big traditional banks facing fintech did just that: publicly they talked up internal ventures and corporate VC, while in reality they kept cutting costs, pruning business lines, and lobbying regulators to keep tech companies out of financial services. Finally, play defense and abandon the old business entirely, and you get the fourth approach: exit. If the old castle falls, build a new one somewhere else. Thomson, a legacy news group, left the media business and turned itself into Thomson Reuters, a provider of professional business information. Film giant Fujifilm has successfully reinvented itself as a healthcare and semiconductor materials company. Recently I've also heard that Canon plans to use its strengths in cameras and sensors to move into autonomous driving. To recap, incumbents have four strategies for dealing with disruptors: fight head-on, double down, retreat and obstruct, or exit. Birkinshaw says none is inherently better than the others. Each has successes and failures. Fighting head-on can give you first-mover advantage, or kill you for moving too early. Retreating and obstructing looks timid, but it can be a smart way to conserve strength and wait for the right moment. Judging by the results, most industry leaders successfully held on to their advantages. For newcomers, that means it's easy to be a spoiler and very hard to be a disruptor. As Jeff Bezos put it: "I very frequently get the question: 'What's going to change in the next 10 years?' And that is a very interesting question; it's a very common one. I almost never get the question: 'What's not going to change in the next 10 years?' And I submit to you that that second question is actually the more important of the two." #DedaoHeadlines

These articles are personal notes, book excerpts, and collected reprints. Figures and events reflect the time of the original publication, are not current information, and do not constitute investment advice.

Share this article
LINEFacebook

Comments

What do you think? Share your experience or questions.

Loading comments…

My reading notes

These notes stay in this browser and are not published. Writing a note also saves the article. Back up or move your notes in My Reading.

Manage my bookmarks and notes →

STAY CURIOUS

Save a good question for your next visit.

Save this article, or follow the Facebook page and RSS feed for additions. Historical articles retain their original publication dates.

Browse All articlesSearch articles and full text →