Fact-check notes (2026-10-29):
1. Phelps laid out the argument in Mass Flourishing (2013) and tested it with data in Dynamism (2020), co-authored with Raicho Bojilov, Hian Teck Hoon, Jonathan Ostry, and Gylfi Zoega. The postwar indigenous innovation rates and country comparisons are from Phelps' 2024 IMF article. Source:
https://www.imf.org/en/publications/fandd/issues/2024/09/point-of-view-mass-flourishing-and-economic-dynamism-edmund-phelps
2. The term "low-desire society" comes from Kenichi Ohmae's 2015 book The Low-Desire Society. Source:
http://ijs.cssn.cn/xsyj/bkwz/202301/t20230118_5583729.shtml
3. The Ford Model T launched on October 1, 1908; the moving assembly line came to the Highland Park plant in October 1913. "Creating a new desire" and "Musk repeating this innovation" are the narrator's interpretation, not historical claims. Sources:
https://www.asme.org/about-asme/engineering-history/landmarks/233-model-t https://guides.loc.gov/this-month-in-business-history/October/Ford
4. Columbia University published an obituary for Phelps (1933–2026) on May 19, 2026. The original post went up on 2026-09-08, after that, so calling him "the late" is consistent. (These notes only verify biographical facts and don't change the original publication date.) Sources:
https://fas.columbia.edu/news/memoriam-professor-emeritus-edmund-phelps https://econ.columbia.edu/in-memory-of-edmund-ned-phelps/
5. Checked against these sources, statements without reliable support were rewritten (2 changes).
----
A look at Dynamism by the late Nobel economist Edmund Phelps. Innovation drives prosperity, and the basic fuel for innovation is every person's deep-seated urge to explore and to change things.
What prosperity really means is "dynamism": how much passion, challenge, growth, and self-expression people experience in their work. A dynamic country has the desire and capability it takes to generate innovation and the will to bring it into the economy.
Silicon Valley produced Intel, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Google, Facebook, Nvidia, and Tesla, and the internet revolution swept the world. It's been one of the great eras of innovation in human history. Yet in established Western European economies, TFP growth kept falling. (TFP, or total factor productivity, is the extra output you get from better technology, efficiency, or allocation after you strip out growth in labor and capital.) No matter how much governments cut taxes or central banks printed money, TFP growth wouldn't budge. The result was sluggish growth, rising populism, and a string of related problems.
Phelps' diagnosis: Europe has intellectual elites but lacks grassroots innovators. It has a deep history but lacks forward energy. Modern values create desire, desire produces grassroots dynamism, dynamism drives homegrown innovation, and that innovation ultimately brings mass flourishing.
Innovation starts with modern values. These aren't abstractions. The question is simple: do ordinary people in a society broadly have a hunger to explore, an urge to create, the nerve to take risks on the unknown, and a drive to find meaning and fulfillment in their work?
When those values take hold across a society, you get grassroots economic dynamism. In every industry, from the corner-store owner to the assembly-line worker, from the salesperson at a bank to the product manager in an office, people have the freedom and the impulse to try new methods, improve processes, and find new uses.
Phelps ran extensive cross-country data analysis, and the conclusion pointed in one clear direction: a country's innovative energy depends heavily on how much its culture supports individualism, risk-taking, and self-expression.
Compare countries' cultural values with their TFP growth and you see a strong positive correlation. In that analysis the U.S. is practically a unicorn. The values measured include how willing people are to take risks, how much independent thinking is encouraged, and how much rule-breaking is respected.
Since World War II, the U.S. has been in a league of its own on homegrown innovation, far ahead of Europe and other rich countries. Even during the global slowdown, America's decline was relatively mild, and it bounced back with the internet wave of the 1990s.
What did America get right? Phelps' answer: a culture of dynamism. The U.S. is a nation of immigrants, a place where you're allowed to fail and start over. That soil feeds an endless stream of grassroots innovation. The chain doesn't start with macro policy or a technical breakthrough. It starts with a belief: life can be changed, the world can be remade, and individual imagination and ability are worth something. "You're capable of more than you think."
(See the earlier post on Steve Jobs.)
European tradition, by contrast, puts more weight on stability, welfare, and security. Those values do a lot for social fairness, but they hold back individual risk-taking and innovation.
Innovation also works on both sides of the economy. It keeps opening up new sources of growth on the supply side, and it sparks new desires and demand on the consumer side.
Phelps' data show the U.S. leading on homegrown innovation, with an indigenous innovation rate of 1.02, ahead of the UK (0.76), Finland (0.55), Germany (0.42), Italy (0.40), and France (0.32). Continental Europe, especially Germany, France, and Italy, contributed very little original innovation. Their growth relied heavily on importing innovation from elsewhere.
In early 20th-century America, Henry Ford declared that every family should own a car. With an improved assembly line, he built the Model T, a car with incredible value for the money. It didn't just revolutionize industrial production and turn the car from a luxury into a mass-market product. More importantly, it created a new desire, a new kind of consumer demand. That desire powered America's economic takeoff and reshaped its modern industry and consumer society. Today Elon Musk seems to be repeating that great innovation, just with a more advanced product: the Tesla EV.
Japan in the same era is the cautionary tale. Starting in the 1990s, Japan fell into a strange state: its economy stalled. But what was scarier than the stagnation was that the whole society's desire vanished. This is what's called a "low-desire society." Young people don't want to start companies, don't want to fight for promotions, don't even want to marry or have kids. The country entered its Lost Thirty Years. The economy didn't grow, but the deeper problem was that people lost the ability to dream.
America on one side, Western Europe and Japan on the other, illustrate one truth: the root driver of prosperity isn't technology and it isn't capital. It's desire, or more precisely, the passion and drive to create. If something is broken at the level of a country's culture, no amount of policy stimulus or infrastructure spending will fix it. You're treating symptoms, not the disease.
#DedaoAudiobook #Dynamism
----
Robin: "What worries me most is Taiwan following Japan into the 'low-desire society' trap: young people who don't want to compete, don't want to work hard, don't want to marry or have kids. That leads to a long, drawn-out slump. Taiwan can't let its young people lose the drive to dream.
One more thing. Taiwan has to actively encourage innovation and creativity. If young people aspire to get rich quick in the stock market and idolize teenage day-trading 'stock gods' instead of entrepreneurs who put in the work to get better and grind it out, that will shape their values, their future, and the country's long-term development."
Comments
What do you think? Share your experience or questions.
Sign in to comment, reply or like. Sign in / Sign up
Loading comments…