Fact-check note (2026-10-28):
1. “From 1984 to 2000… more than 20,000 stores” should read: at the end of fiscal 2000 (October 1, 2000), Starbucks had about 3,501 stores worldwide (2,619 company-operated, 530 licensed in North America, and 352 licensed internationally, summing the 10-K line items). Source:
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/829224/000089102000002203/0000891020-00-002203.txt
2. “The most times a customer visited in a month was 18”: in a 2004 interview, Starbucks staff said its most frequent customers came in about 18 times a month. It should read “the most loyal customers visit about 18 times a month.” Source:
https://www.fool.com/specials/2004/02/02/foolcom-starbucks-starry-statistics-spec.aspx
3. Huawei’s devices business making up more than half: in 2019 its consumer business brought in RMB 467.3 billion, 54.4% of total revenue. Source:
https://www-file.huawei.com/-/media/CORPORATE/PDF/annual-report/annual_report_2019_cn.pdf
4. IBM’s early products: “cheese slicers” should be automatic meat slicers; the others were scales and time clocks. Sources:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computing-Tabulating-Recording_Company https://www.ibm.com/history/ctr-and-ibm
5. The origin story of Sichuan cuisine (boat haulers on the Jialing River scavenging offal, the birth of Chongqing hot pot): no reliable historical record could be found. It’s a popular legend, used here as a metaphor, not as history.
----
#BreakOutOfYourNiche
In Chinese internet slang, “breaking out of the circle” describes a specific moment. A celebrity or influencer has a small fan base, and then one day they start reaching people outside it. That’s breaking out.
The phrase now gets used in all kinds of fields: going from a small audience to a big one.
----
The history of human civilization is also a history of breaking out. Many of the world’s major religions began in Asia—Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity, Islam. Over time they spread, Christianity most of all, moving from the eastern Mediterranean into Europe and eventually around the world.
----
Take Sichuan food. It started with one flavor profile: numbing and spicy. Every ingredient got smothered in it, which made it rich and one-note at the same time—a little painful to eat, and deeply satisfying.
[Editor’s note: what follows is a popular legend, used here as a metaphor, not as history.]
It didn’t start as a cuisine at all. Its roots go back to about the poorest, lowliest people you can imagine: boat haulers, the men who made a living dragging barges upriver by hand.
The haulers along the Jialing River burned through a huge amount of energy every day and needed protein. On their wages, they couldn’t afford meat every day. But while they were hauling, they noticed offal—animal innards—would float down the river now and then.
Conditions were rough. They had one pot and whatever firewood they could pick up on the riverbank. To eat ingredients that might already smell off, they had to bury the funk under massive amounts of numbing, spicy, salty seasoning. Then they could get to the good part: the taste of meat.
That, the story goes, was the first Chongqing hot pot. Gradually people who were better off tried it too, and it caught on in Chongqing and eastern Sichuan, then across China.
That’s a classic breakout.
----
The phrase is a little misleading, though. It sounds like you walk out of your small circle into a bigger one. That’s not really what happens. The haulers didn’t go out to the masses or travel the country. The people outside the circle came to them.
From the outside, it looks like your influence escaped your circle. What’s actually going on is that something distinctive about you—something original that also has broad appeal—gets embraced by more and more people. That’s a breakout.
Plenty of companies have done it. IBM is one. It started out making scales, meat slicers, and time clocks, then moved to mainframes and PCs, and later to all kinds of e-business solutions.
Huawei is another. It started with telecom network equipment; today its devices business is more than half the company.
Swiss watches are a textbook case too. Watches used to be worn only by men, and not even all men. Swatch Group was especially good at breaking out: it got women who didn’t wear watches to wear them, and got men who didn’t wear jewelry to wear it.
For women, a watch became an accessory tied to fast-changing fashion. So women not only bought watches, they bought them far more often. For men, a watch stopped being a simple timekeeping tool and became jewelry that signaled identity, status, and wealth. That’s a breakout in itself.
Cirque du Soleil took the circus and turned it into mass-market entertainment with only traces of circus left in it.
In that sense, breaking out is one of the biggest patterns in how companies grow.
----
[How Starbucks broke out]
Breaking out is a classic growth model.
Starbucks’ history is one breakout after another. It goes back to 1971, a shop in Seattle that sold coffee beans.
Coffee was already a huge industry before Starbucks. Think coffee and you thought Nescafé or Maxwell House; it was a mainstream drink across the West. In that world Starbucks was a rounding error. It started in a tiny, oddball niche: whole beans.
Instant coffee had gone mainstream, and Starbucks went the opposite way. Its coffee took time, effort, and money, and it was complicated to make. In an era when life was speeding up, it was swimming against the tide.
For its first 13 years, from 1971 to 1984, it grew slowly in a niche that couldn’t have been much smaller. After 1984 it took off. In the next 16 years, from 1984 to 2000, it grew to more than 20,000 stores worldwide.
Today Starbucks is a massive coffee empire. How did it get there? How does a niche that small become a business empire?
In other words: how exactly did Starbucks break out? What’s the logic?
1. Coffee, or the coffee shop?
You may have seen two lines printed on Luckin Coffee cups (Luckin is a Chinese app-based coffee chain): Are you drinking coffee or the coffee shop? You should only pay for the coffee. It sounds pretty smug: stop paying the Starbucks sucker tax and come drink ours.
What the copywriter didn’t realize is that he was judging one logic by the rules of another.
A key dimension of Starbucks looks completely redundant and worthless from Luckin’s point of view. And precisely because Luckin can’t see it, its fight with Starbucks looks a lot like Don Quixote tilting at windmills. Luckin doesn’t get that what Starbucks sells is the coffee shop, not the coffee.
And it isn’t really a coffee shop. It’s a third place. The third place is somewhere that isn’t home and isn’t work. In the past, that place was church. People today don’t go to church as much; they go to a substitute, a kind of secular, commercial pilgrimage.
What’s a pilgrimage? It’s longing for a place that your imagination has polished to perfection. When you get there, you feel plugged into some energy or force, and suddenly you feel much bigger than yourself. That’s less a religious experience than a consumer one.
Starbucks’ third place works on every sense you have. You may feel like you just wandered in, but the visual design, the lighting and colors, the counter, the whole layout of the store have all been carefully designed. You’re hooked before you notice.
Sound matters too. Starbucks has its own signed singers and musicians, and the music it plays isn’t something you hear elsewhere. Then there’s the sound of beans being ground and roasted, which gives you a sudden sense of stepping back in time.
There’s smell: the aroma that comes off the grinder. And of course the taste of the coffee, and how the staff treat you, the vibe they give off. All of it creates a familiarity and sense of belonging you can’t quite put into words.
About 20 years ago, a survey found that Starbucks’ most loyal customers came in up to 18 times a month. It’s a bit like a close friend—the person you most want to call when you’re bored. Starbucks creates that kind of invisible pull.
2. How the pull works
Starbucks’ logo is a siren, from Greek mythology. She sings on an island, and her song is so beautiful you can’t help but come ashore and get closer—and then she eats you. It’s a force you can’t resist.
The logo tells you what breaking out really means. You don’t go into other circles; people from other circles can’t help gathering around you. Starbucks’ business model and customer base are concentric circles. At the center is a group of coffee obsessives who know what the best beans look like, exactly how dark to roast them, and what it takes to grind them right.
Starbucks’ customers are arranged the same way. The ripple effect of that concentric structure on customer influence is what let it build such a huge customer base.
So breaking out isn’t so much leaving your circle as having more and more people outside it drawn in by some kind of pull. How does a small circle generate that pull? Is there a kind of gravity in society, too?
If you sort society by coffee, you first get people who drink it and people who don’t. Among the drinkers, some drink instant, some drink pods, and some are obsessives about their machines and beans.
What Starbucks does first is create a field. That field draws in the original obsessives—the wizards, if you will—into the third place. That creates a core-and-periphery structure, a wizards-and-Muggles structure. The Muggles have tiers too. Some sit close to the wizards and feel a certain kinship with them. Then a pull develops between the upper, middle, and lower tiers of Muggles.
When Starbucks was opening stores, there were two big debates. First, should smoking be allowed? Second, should it sell hot food?
Starbucks is all about the senses, and smell is a huge part of that. Smoke ruins the aroma, and so does hot food. Allowing smoking might have brought in more people, but it would have destroyed the core—the yeast for the whole community. Same with hot food: it might have lifted sales, but it would have wrecked the most essential thing.
That almost harsh filtering of customers actually creates more pull.
The Adventures of Tom Sawyer opens with exactly this kind of story. Aunt Polly punishes Tom by making him whitewash the fence on a Saturday. His first instinct is to get out of it and find someone to do it for him. He starts with a basic business deal—I’ll fetch your water if you paint my fence—and it goes nowhere.
Then he switches modes. He throws himself into painting, as if he’s in a flow state. The boy who comes by to make fun of him sees how absorbed he is and gets curious, while Tom keeps acting like he’s lost in the work and hasn’t even noticed anyone is there.
When the boy asks to have a go, Tom tells him that maybe one boy in a thousand could do it right, and he isn’t that boy. The boy offers half his apple. Tom says no. The boy offers the whole apple. Tom reluctantly agrees—but only for a couple of boards.
By making access limited and privileged, Tom makes the other kid value it. The rest of the boys line up and trade their toys and snacks for the right to paint. A strict filter, and the sense of privilege that comes from limited access, makes everyone want in.
Forbidden fruit tempts. Obstacles create pull. That’s Tom Sawyer economics, and it’s the most important logic behind how Starbucks broke out.
Twain makes the point himself in that chapter: work is whatever you’re obliged to do, and play is whatever you’re not. Grinding away in the hot sun is drudgery; climbing a mountain in the same sun is noble sport. Offer to pay people to work in the heat and they often turn you down. So why do people pay their own money, even risk their lives, to do something hard? Because of human nature. We always have a strong urge to take on challenges, taboos, and obstacles, and to overcome the feeling that we’re small and inadequate.
Those moments don’t come up much in everyday life, but everyone has that urge and that longing. The question is whether there’s a setting that triggers it.
[The power of meaning]
That leads to another topic: meaning as a source of power. Why will someone scrimp and save for a Louis Vuitton bag, or, as the joke goes, sell a kidney for an iPhone? Because people need meaning to make them feel bigger.
As individuals, we all feel small and inadequate. If there’s a way to connect that small self to something much larger, you get a powerful sense of strength, pride, and superiority. And if no system of meaning lifts you up, a sense of inadequacy hangs on.
Once a lonely individual connects to a system of meaning, the boost is obvious. We always exist as individuals, but we always crave belonging to a community, a group, an organization. We live to connect to something much bigger than ourselves.
So the world ends up with two kinds of coffee. With one, you’re drinking the coffee. With the other, you’re drinking the feeling of coffee. With one, you pay only for the coffee. With the other, you pay a lot for everything beyond the coffee.
Notice, too, that some products are born symbolic. Coffee is one. Company growth means market expansion; breaking out is one form of market expansion; and at its core, a breakout runs on the pull of the meaning a product offers.
There’s another way to expand a market: the pull of price. Keep performance the same, or only slightly lower, cut the price hard, and you create a huge pull.
And there’s a third way that combines the two: a product with obvious pull from meaning that also has some pull on price. In fact, a lot of the products we see fall into this third category.
The worst case is a product with no pull from meaning, or even negative pull—buying it makes people feel they’re cutting themselves off from something. On top of that, performance is clearly worse, and the price cut can’t make up for either the weaker performance or the missing meaning. A product like that won’t break out, and it’s an open question whether it even has a circle to begin with.
#Dedao #WuBofanBusinessReview
Comments
What do you think? Share your experience or questions.
Sign in to comment, reply or like. Sign in / Sign up
Loading comments…