Entrepreneurship & Strategy

Quibi’s Rapid Collapse: Resources Are Not the Same as Understanding Users

Share this article
LINEFacebook

Reposted commentary (WeChat source linked in post; original author not verified)

Storage information

Bookmarks and reading positions are stored in this browser. Manage and back them up in My Reading.

Collected in Robin Shen’s Field Notes · Content type and attribution are shown above

English version published 2026-11-08 with AI assistance. Attribution, source notes, and verification limits are retained in the text. 中文原文

Reading guide

Quibi's short life is a reminder for founders that a star team and a mountain of capital can't replace understanding how people actually use a product and what they'll pay for. The original commentary is kept; third-party estimates and the company's responses are presented side by side, and unverified surveys are flagged.

Key points

  • Resources and a star team can't replace understanding your users
  • The 8% figure is a third-party estimate, which the company publicly disputed at the time
Entrepreneurship & Strategy thematic illustration
Entrepreneurship & Strategy · Thematic illustration · AI generated

Full text — English translation

Fact-check notes (2026-10-31): 1. AP reported on October 21, 2020 that Quibi announced it would wind down and sell its assets; the shutdown wasn't fully completed that day. This piece is business commentary from the time, and its account of why Quibi failed is the author's view. Source: https://apnews.com/article/virus-outbreak-jeffrey-katzenberg-meg-whitman-16d51752e9d80ac8dc45e7641213a690 2. The 8% conversion rate in the post comes from a July 2020 Sensor Tower estimate of people who downloaded the app in its first three days: of about 910,000 downloaders, about 72,000 stayed on after the 90-day free trial ended. It is not a confirmed conversion rate across all Quibi users. Source: https://www.theverge.com/2020/7/8/21318060/quibi-subscriber-count-free-trial-paying-users-conversion-rate 3. Quibi told The Verge at the time that the paid-subscriber estimate was off by an order of magnitude and that cumulative downloads had passed 5.6 million. The company said its download-to-trial ratio beat mobile app benchmarks and that conversion to paid was strong for both April's 90-day trials and May and June's 14-day trials, but it didn't disclose specific paid numbers or rates. These are a third-party estimate and the company's response; this note doesn't judge which is right. Source: https://www.theverge.com/2020/7/8/21318060/quibi-subscriber-count-free-trial-paying-users-conversion-rate 4. No original survey or sample data was found for "70% of viewers thought it was a food delivery app." The ad rankings, marketing budget, and other unsourced figures haven't been verified individually either; keeping them in the text doesn't mean they're confirmed. The full text behind the WeChat link in the original post couldn't be retrieved for checking. 5. The 10 Emmy nominations and two wins match Variety's reporting that year. That supports only the award numbers, not any conclusion about content quality or audience preferences. Sources: https://variety.com/2020/tv/news/quibi-earns-10-emmy-nominations-in-rare-bright-spot-for-struggling-streamer-1234718202/ https://variety.com/2020/tv/news/quibi-first-emmys-wins-1234774206/ ---- #QuibisRapidCollapse Streaming platform Quibi officially announced on October 21 that it was shutting down. Quibi was once a rising star startup with a glittering founding team and investor list, including Disney, eOne, Fox, ITV, Lionsgate, and MGM, which together put in $1.75 billion. In an open letter, the founders wrote: "Quibi was a big idea and no one wanted it to succeed more than us. Our failure was not for lack of trying; we've considered and exhausted every option available to us." It was born with a halo, launched with a splash, and surrounded by stars. Then it stumbled out of the gate, went looking for a buyer, and died. Quibi may have been the brightest shooting star of the summer, and for anyone paying attention, its rise and fall is a lesson worth remembering for founders and investors alike. Quibi's biggest mistake was imagining an ideal user instead of truly understanding how real users behave and think. It's surprising that a team packed with elite talent could trip over something so basic and miss chance after chance to recover. It's another wake-up call for founders: beware of relying on the playbook that made you successful before. Markets and users change fast. Stay sharp and stay humble. ---- There are two kinds of startups. One is the scrappy kind, built from nothing and kept alive by fresh capital from investors. The other is born with a silver spoon in its mouth, short on neither people nor money. Quibi was clearly the second kind. Quibi glittered from the founding team on down. Founder Jeffrey Katzenberg co-founded DreamWorks and is a Hollywood heavyweight producer. CEO Meg Whitman had run eBay and HP and was a veteran tech executive. The two tapped their networks to poach a wave of executives from Disney, Netflix, Snapchat, and other giants. You couldn't ask for a more star-studded lineup. With that team behind it, Quibi raised $1.75 billion before launch, from Hollywood studios like Disney, WarnerMedia, and Sony Pictures as well as top-tier firms like Goldman Sachs and Alibaba. Quibi launched in April 2020, with a crowd of stars, including director Guillermo del Toro (The Shape of Water), actor Kevin Hart (Jumanji), and Jennifer Lopez, lining up to put their own shows on the platform. A company that star-studded looked like it had an unlimited future. Yet just six months after launch, it was dealing with weak user growth, skeptical advertisers, pay cuts for the management team, and a technology patent lawsuit. By the end of September, reports said it was looking to sell. Today "Quibi is DEAD!" is splashed across the headlines of every major tech outlet. ---- Katzenberg had decades of producing experience. He'd lived through the rise of the TV era and believed phones would transform TV just as dramatically. With Quibi he wanted to "reinvent television." So he went after Gen Z's spare moments: Hollywood-quality series and shows in 10-minute episodes, made for the phone. Beyond the shows themselves, Quibi pushed a viewing technology called Turnstyle. You could watch the same show holding your phone horizontally or vertically and get a different view. Horizontal was the wide shot, vertical was the close-up, and you could switch seamlessly at any time without interrupting playback. Some directors came up with special tricks. In the thriller Wireless, for example, horizontal mode played normally and was nothing special. Turn the phone vertical and the screen switched to the main character's phone, so you could watch him make calls and send texts from a first-person view. Quibi was downloaded 300,000 times on launch day and briefly hit No. 3 on Apple's App Store. But dreams always look beautiful. Who knew the next few months would show that nearly every feature Quibi was proud of would turn into a trap. ---- A poor user experience #NotEnoughContent On content, Quibi was benchmarking itself against Netflix, HBO, and Disney+, focusing on high-quality professional content. It signed a long list of A-list Hollywood production teams and stars, and its most expensive shows cost as much as $100,000 per minute. Deep pockets and careful craftsmanship earned Quibi 10 Emmy nominations in 2020 and two wins. But glory at the awards doesn't help when users won't pay. Quibi never produced a breakout hit that got people talking. In fact, even with big money on the table, the best scripts still went to Netflix, HBO, and other established platforms first. Big platforms mean more exposure and attention, and Quibi's user base was tiny next to their hundreds of millions of viewers. So Quibi was a second choice for top creators, and behind the A-list production hype there may have been only second-rate scripts. TV shows and unscripted series take a long time to produce. To fill out its library, Quibi brought in old shows and news briefs. Gen Z opened Quibi and was baffled: This is it? What's wrong with Netflix and YouTube? #TooExpensive Quibi launched with a three-month free trial and got 1.5 million downloads in its first week. After the trial, users had to pay $4.99 a month with ads or $7.99 without. As soon as that kicked in, savvy users walked away without a second thought. So far, Quibi's conversion rate to paid users is only 8%. The exodus was no surprise. Compare subscription prices across streaming platforms: Netflix's basic plan was $8.99 and Disney+ started at $5.83. Neither was cheap, but both had far more content than Quibi, and they kept 30% and 14% of users, respectively, after their trials ended. Why not go free with ads? Because Quibi already had plenty of ads. Since launch, it had signed one-year deals with 10 advertisers. Every video came with an unskippable 6-, 10-, or 15-second pre-roll ad. Relying on ads alone would have meant even more of them, hurting the viewing experience and making it even harder for a new product that hadn't found its footing to keep users. #MarketingThatTiedItsOwnHands If the content doesn't excite and the price isn't friendly, a smart marketing campaign might still spark some buzz. Sadly, Quibi's baffling choices threw away wave after wave of attention. To protect copyrights, Quibi, like other paid streaming platforms, blocked screenshots. Hit your phone's screenshot button and the screen went black. The product team got a flood of complaints about not being able to take screenshots or share. Three months later they finally came up with a "clever" fix: press and hold the screen, a menu pops up, slide your finger to the screenshot button (and the first time, grant Quibi access to your photos). Even as it practically disarmed itself on social media, Quibi spent freely on other marketing channels. To support its launch, it bought premium airtime during the 2020 Oscars and the Super Bowl. Unfortunately, a $120 million budget made only a small splash. By one count, the 2020 Oscars drew about 23.6 million viewers, an all-time low, and most of them weren't Quibi's target audience. The rating among 18-to-49-year-olds was just 5.3. Buying ads during the Super Bowl, America's biggest TV event, was clearly a smarter move. But this time Quibi fell down on the creative. Of the 62 Super Bowl ads that year, Quibi's ranked fourth from the bottom with viewers. More embarrassing still, 70% of viewers thought Quibi was a food delivery app after watching it. Marketing is the art of talking and listening: saying the right thing to the right people at the right time and place. Quibi managed to miss on all three. Search Quibi's promotional materials and the keywords that keep coming up are the founders' names, the Hollywood star lineup, and the viewing tech. To ordinary viewers, that was far less appealing than a set of Baby Yoda memes. On Twitter and Instagram, Quibi posted stills and trailers to a lonely audience, with little engagement and hardly any influencer likes or shares. Quibi said it was targeting young people, but its marketing was very old-school. On that front, all that effort was wasted. #FuzzyPositioning At root, Quibi stepped into all these traps because it never figured out its product positioning. Time spent on smartphones and watching video really has been growing in recent years. But that doesn't mean the market will pay for "Gen Z + spare moments + premium short-form video." Each of those three pieces deserves a hard look. Did Quibi match Gen Z's habits and spending power? In today's creator culture, internet personalities may get as much attention as traditional movie stars, yet you couldn't find work from any well-known YouTubers on Quibi. What do people do with their spare moments? Scroll Instagram, play games, browse Twitter, listen to podcasts... There are endless ways to kill time. Even if you narrow it to video streaming, there's YouTube, TikTok, Snapchat, and plenty more. Quibi's differentiation wasn't enough to win people over. Do viewers like premium short-form video? To some extent, yes. The success of Netflix's Love, Death & Robots and Disney+'s Star Wars: The Clone Wars shows there's real potential. But Quibi's mobile-only focus drove the product into a dead end. For beautifully shot premium series, viewers have always preferred to settle in and watch on a big screen. Early on, Quibi promoted Turnstyle and didn't support watching on other screens. That severely limited when and where people could use it and wasted a lot of carefully shot footage. The product and the target user were pulling against each other, producing an awkward streaming app that makes you wonder whether the Quibi team ever seriously studied what the market wanted. Katzenberg set out to reinvent TV, and in the end it looks like he just stuffed TV into a phone. The Guardian once delivered a sharp verdict: Quibi was "born in an LA conference room and will die in the real world." Sitting in that LA conference room, Katzenberg and Whitman had plenty of industry connections and money. What they lacked was an understanding of the younger generation itself. Both in their sixties, they were far removed from social media and short-form video, and they relied on imagination to replay their past experience while ignoring market feedback. Quibi's failure is a lesson for industry veterans who want to start companies. ----- https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/F0Hpc-3Z2CrwvNrikxXmIQ

These articles are personal notes, book excerpts, and collected reprints. Figures and events reflect the time of the original publication, are not current information, and do not constitute investment advice.

Share this article
LINEFacebook

Comments

What do you think? Share your experience or questions.

Loading comments…

My reading notes

These notes stay in this browser and are not published. Writing a note also saves the article. Back up or move your notes in My Reading.

Manage my bookmarks and notes →

STAY CURIOUS

Save a good question for your next visit.

Save this article, or follow the Facebook page and RSS feed for additions. Historical articles retain their original publication dates.

Browse All articlesSearch articles and full text →